-One of the fiew really good usages of the Wii-motion
-unique and chilling atmosphere
-great and deep story
-Story not just told in cutscenes, but through gameplay as well
-unique and innovative take on the Horror-genre

I liked it. It was meh

www.edge-online.com/features/the-making-of-silent-hill-shattered-memories

„In the publisher reviews the question would always be ‘Are you trying to make a game where you just walk around and nothing happens?’. I was like ‘No, but that’s a valid experience’.”

The 50 best games of the console generation (The Telegraph)

"A wonderful, haunting piece of video game storytelling. Shattered Memories was more of an understated ghost walk than a traditional video game horror, but its psychological impact was devastating. Shattered Memories’ daring differences should be celebrated; it’s one of the most innovative and enjoyable survival horrors for many a year."

An atmospheric and interesting attempt at a Silent Hill remake, but unfortunately nothing more. Playing it feels like watching those Hollywood remakes of Japanese horror movies - for all the gimmicks, trickery and the occasional attempt at a homage to the original, part of me feels that they just don't get it. Lack of subtlety, a plot twist you can see coming a mile off, the only positive aspect being that Shattered Memories tries to do something new with the series, the same way The Room attempted it and was (in my opinion) a step in the right direction, before Homecoming came along and took thirty steps backwards to the point where it was almost a Silent Hill parody. In any case, sometimes it's better to just let a good thing die.

Much different than other games in the series Silent Hill: Shattered Memories really is a physiological experience. The game doesn't have combat, when monsters appear you have to run, and it makes the game much more frightening, though the fact they're always foreshadowed by ice is disappointing as it eliminates tension and makes the game not very scary. Also the game basically punishes you for exploring when it comes to it's multiple endings. But aside from these caveats the game is great, there's a big world to explore that's not entirely linear a great changeable story (the game watches what you do and changes the game based on it) and fun simple puzzles. It's short but has a lot of replayability. Definitely worth playing