An atmospheric and interesting attempt at a Silent Hill remake, but unfortunately nothing more. Playing it feels like watching those Hollywood remakes of Japanese horror movies - for all the gimmicks, trickery and the occasional attempt at a homage to the original, part of me feels that they just don't get it. Lack of subtlety, a plot twist you can see coming a mile off, the only positive aspect being that Shattered Memories tries to do something new with the series, the same way The Room attempted it and was (in my opinion) a step in the right direction, before Homecoming came along and took thirty steps backwards to the point where it was almost a Silent Hill parody. In any case, sometimes it's better to just let a good thing die.